Work in a marina,in water half way up boot, jet wash in them, walk a lot, they get muddy a lot. Not leaked once in over a year, sole has worn through on heal. Cleaned and polished with beeswax.

I'm amazed people saying these are not waterproof. These are the most waterproof boots I've ever owned. They are my 1st pair of leather boots. Usually buy synthetic/goretex boots. Heavier but dry feet

Had these boots for over 3 years, done Yorkshire 3 peaks twice in them, climbed many mountains in the Yorkshire dales and only just given up on me from wear on the heel inside.
Very comfortable A*

I’ve had the boots for 6 months and they were comfortable from the start. I’ve kept them regularly waxed to retain the waterproofing but after 3 hours in the rain yesterday, my feet were wet.

Solid shoe from straight out of the box, no problems walking through at grass or fords. Stable, comfy and durable. The breakup... Next to the heal on the inside lining perished, blister and returned.

I've had these for about 6 months and they have got progressively worse despite proper care. Now I get wet feet walking through wet grass.
Comfortable? Yes. Waterproof? Not in the slightest.

A decent value for money boot but be careful. They're not made for tough terrain or long walks. I walked a mountain path for 20 kms, the soles are not firm enough, feet were v.sore.ok for upto 8km.

Bought these 12 months ago for just walking my dog. After 12 months the leather has cracked and I get wet feet every time i walk through wet grass.
I have treated religiously with Granger wax.

Had these just over 12 months and can unreservedly recommend them. Used for fishing, so were walked in through mud and long grass then kept on for hours; comfortable, warm and waterproof every time.

Bought these in March this year and they are comfortable and waterproof.The vibram soles seem hard wearing.I keep them waxed using Gwax which keeps them supple and maintains the waterproofing.

After thorough testing on the Wainwrights and Munros and on longer trails like the Cleveland Way and WHW these boots survived it all. Recommend going a larger size than your street shoe. Excellent!

Got these in anticipation for walking the West Highland way. Did not disappoint, feet were kept dry and comfortable. I'd recommend breaking them in a little longer than usual

My 2nd pair of these boots, first pair lasted 2 yrs before being worn out and no longer waterproof, this pair only lasted less than 9 months before leather cracked and they started to leak.

Had these boots just over a year. Comfy, solid, good firm and confident footing! Highly recommend!

Best hiking boots I have EVER purchased.I’m fortunate enough that I can hike every day between 10km to 30km over all types of terrain in S -Wales.Comfortable,Waterproof,excellent Wear/Tear. 5 *****

Had them over 12 months and done 500 plus miles. Been brilliant so far but starting to get slight water ingress in extreme conditions and soles feeling a bit thin. Used on hard hill walks so excellent

Boots are great very comfortable

Great boots nice and comfortable, would recommend them.

Not had the opportunity to test properly yet, but they are very comfortable. They feel slightly heavy to me but as I’m brand new to walking perhaps that’s just me being used to the activity.

Very comfortable boots. No trouble wearing them in either. Good buy so far thanks!